Burt's Bees Cucumber & Mint Wipes Review: 8.2/10
Sweaty summer errands and a sealed pack that won’t turn into a dry, scratchy disappointment are the two images that keep popping up around Burt's Bees Cucumber & Mint Face Wipes (30 Ct, 3-Pack). Across thousands of Amazon reviews, people frame these as a dependable “anywhere cleanse” that feels more like skincare than a harsh makeup wipe. The overall tone is positive, but not starry-eyed: a noticeable minority gets hung up on scent strength or a stinging sensation, and some find mascara removal only average. Verdict from the crowd: a solid everyday wipe with some scent-related risk, 8.2/10 based on sentiment in the supplied reviews.
Quick Verdict
Conditional Yes.
| What users focus on | Pros (from users) | Cons (from users) |
|---|---|---|
| Everyday cleansing & refresh | Often leaves skin “soft” and not tight | Some report “burn” or irritation |
| Makeup removal | Works well for most makeup, easy one‑step use | Waterproof mascara/liner can take extra effort |
| Scent experience | Many call it “super fresh” or soothing | Others say the sage/cucumber scent “stinks” or is too strong |
| Packaging & dryness | Resealable pack praised for staying moist | A few dislike opening design/pull‑out control |
| Value for routine use | Seen as worth paying a bit more | Price is higher than basic wipes |
Claims vs Reality
Marketing claim #1: “Gentle cleansing for sensitive skin, no harsh scrubbing.”
Digging deeper into user reports, many sensitive‑skin buyers say the promise holds. One Amazon reviewer described the effect as reliable and non‑tightening: “very gentle on sensitive skin… doesn’t leave your skin feeling dry and tight like many other cleansers.” Another buyer framed it simply as routine‑safe: “This product simply and safely cleans my sensitive skin on a daily basis.” For people who struggle with redness or post‑cleanse tightness, these wipes read as a low‑drama option.
But a clear counter‑thread exists. A verified buyer on Amazon noted: “the sensitive wipes have no burn like the scented ones… but I also experienced the burn.” While the brand positions the cucumber & mint line as gentle, multiple users report stinging or tingling, suggesting the “gentle” experience may depend on personal tolerance to fragrance or mint extracts. While officially formulated for sensitive skin, some people still feel irritation.
Marketing claim #2: “Removes makeup, even mascara, in one easy step.”
Many users back this up for normal makeup days. A verified buyer on Amazon said: “they also get make up off completely if you haven’t used primer.” Another added that the wipes are “quick, easy, & refreshing,” emphasizing convenience for rushed routines. People treat them as an end‑of‑day reset or travel shortcut rather than a full multi‑step cleanse.
Reality is a bit less triumphant around eye makeup. The beauty blog review (Angela Woodward) wrote that the wipes “remove your makeup, but they have a little struggle with mascara and waterproof liner.” That matches smaller Amazon hints that they work best when makeup isn’t heavily set or waterproof. Users don’t call the wipes ineffective, but they often frame mascara removal as “typical” rather than exceptional.
Marketing claim #3: “Refreshing cucumber and mint scent.”
Some buyers love this angle. An Amazon reviewer praised a “super fresh” smell and said the wipes “don’t make my skin oily at all.” Another called them a heat‑day lifesaver: “these cleaned all the dirt and oil off my face left me feeling refreshed and cooler.” For users seeking a cooling, spa‑ish wipe, the scent and after‑feel are central to why they repurchase.
On the flip side, fragrance is the most polarizing part of the experience. One Amazon reviewer was blunt: “green package stinks… this smells like a dill pickle that has been rolled around in the dirt.” Another blogger said the scent was “too strong… literally gives me a headache.” So while the brand sells “refreshing,” the data suggests a real risk that the herbal cucumber‑mint profile reads overpowering or unpleasant for some noses.
Cross-Platform Consensus
Universally Praised
A recurring pattern emerged around how these feel on skin after wiping. Instead of the stripped, squeaky finish common in cheaper wipes, many users describe a soft, comfortable aftermath. A verified buyer on Amazon highlighted that their skin feels “soft, not like I need to immediately put on a moisturizer.” Another said the wipes “don’t leave your skin feeling dry and tight,” which matters most to dry‑skin and sensitive‑skin users who often avoid wipes altogether. For those people, the implication is big: a wipe that doesn’t force an immediate follow‑up moisturizer can function as a true “late‑night shortcut.”
Convenience is the second big praise thread, especially for travel, gym bags, and hot‑weather situations. One Amazon buyer wrote: “i bought them on a really hot day of shopping… these cleaned all the dirt and oil off my face left me feeling refreshed and cooler.” Another called them “quick, easy, and refreshing,” even mentioning tearing them in half to stretch a pack—an informal nod to portability and size. Users aren’t romanticizing; they’re leaning on them for practical moments when a sink isn’t nearby.
Packaging reliability also earns steady compliments. A verified Amazon buyer said: “I have complete confidence in the packaging… it seals really well, meaning the towelettes won’t dry out.” For frequent wipe users, that’s a real quality marker because dried‑out packs often turn a product into waste. The praise suggests these stay moist enough to be trusted in bags or over weeks of use.
Finally, many buyers see the price‑to‑quality balance as favorable. One Amazon review called them “some of the best you’ll find. worth the extra price.” This shows up among users who’ve tried more budget wipes and are willing to pay for a better skin feel and more durable cloth.
Common Complaints
The most consistent complaint is scent dissatisfaction or sensitivity. The negative Amazon quote about a “dill pickle… in the dirt” is extreme but not isolated. The beauty blog reviewer said the cucumber & sage scent was so strong that “the fragrance literally gives me a headache.” These stories matter for fragrance‑averse users or anyone with migraine triggers; the wipes may be a gamble even if the cleansing itself works well.
A second issue is stinging or burning on some skin types. An Amazon reviewer contrasted versions directly: “the sensitive wipes have no burn like the scented ones… but I also experienced the burn.” This suggests that while many sensitive‑skin users are fine, a subgroup reacts poorly to the scented formula. For acne‑prone or barrier‑compromised users, this can turn a convenient wipe into an irritant.
Users also note limitations with waterproof eye makeup. Angela Woodward wrote they “struggle with mascara and waterproof liner,” and another Amazon buyer said they remove makeup “completely if you haven’t used primer,” implying reduced performance with heavier makeup routines. For full‑glam wearers, these may be better as a first pass rather than a single‑step remover.
There are smaller gripes about pack mechanics. The blog review liked the packaging overall but found “it is hard to keep the wipes from pulling too many through.” That affects people who want one‑handed, no‑waste dispensing.
Divisive Features
Scent is the clearest divide. Some people center the pleasant, cooling aroma in their praise. A verified Amazon buyer said: “the scent is super fresh,” and others talk about feeling “refreshed and cooler.” Meanwhile, another Amazon reviewer said: “I really don't like the way this smells… smells like a dill pickle.” So the same “cucumber‑mint” identity reads either spa‑clean or kitchen‑pickle, depending on the person.
There’s also a mild divide on how “gentle” they feel. Many sensitive‑skin users say they cause no tightness or redness, yet others mention a “burn.” The data suggests a mostly gentle reputation with a meaningful minority exception, likely tied to fragrance/mint sensitivity.
Trust & Reliability
The Trustpilot section mirrors Amazon because the supplied verified feedback is the same review pool, and it reinforces a stable pattern rather than raising scam flags. Complaints are about scent or mild irritation, not about counterfeit packs or missing product. The tone of negative reviews is specific (“pickle” smell, “burn”), which typically signals real use experiences rather than suspicious noise.
Long‑term reliability stories show up indirectly in repeat‑purchase language. One Amazon buyer wrote that the wipes are “a winner!” for daily use, and another said they “will definitely buy again.” That kind of casual, routine endorsement suggests these stay consistent enough over time for people to fold them into daily cleansing without surprise performance drops.
Alternatives
Only a few comparisons are hinted at in the data, mainly between Burt’s Bees variants. Angela Woodward notes she tried multiple scents and even preferred papaya’s fragrance but returned to cucumber & sage because “the papaya ones don't work with my skin as well.” This implies the biggest alternative for current users is other Burt’s Bees wipe lines: if you like the cloth and cleansing but hate the cucumber‑mint aroma, switching scents may solve it without changing brands.
Some Amazon feedback compares scented vs sensitive versions: one reviewer praised the sensitive wipes for “no burn,” wishing for “the no burn and the scent” together. That points to Burt’s Bees Sensitive Facial Cleansing Towelettes as the closest internal alternative for irritation‑prone users.
Price & Value
Current retail ranges in the data put a 30‑count pack around $5–$6 at mass retailers, while the 3‑pack lands roughly in the mid‑teens online. eBay listings show the 3‑pack hovering around $14.90 and single packs closer to $8–$9, suggesting mild resale markup but not scarcity pricing. Users who call them “worth the extra price” are signaling a value proposition tied to comfort, not just cleansing.
Community buying behavior also hints at stretching value: one Amazon buyer tears wipes in half and finds that “works just fine,” implying the cloth is large enough to economize. For cost‑sensitive users, that’s a practical tip emerging from real use rather than marketing.
FAQ
Q: Are these actually good for sensitive skin?
A: Many sensitive‑skin reviewers say yes, describing them as “very gentle” and not drying. However, a minority report stinging or “burn” from the scented formula. If you’re fragrance‑reactive, users suggest the unscented/sensitive Burt’s Bees line is safer.
Q: Do they remove waterproof mascara?
A: Users say they handle regular makeup well, but waterproof mascara and liner can take extra effort. The beauty blog reviewer noted a “little struggle with mascara and waterproof liner.” Most treat them as decent but not miraculous for heavy eye looks.
Q: How strong is the cucumber & mint scent?
A: Experiences split sharply. Some Amazon buyers call it “super fresh” and soothing, while others say it “stinks” or is so strong it causes headaches. If you’re scent‑sensitive, this is the biggest gamble mentioned.
Q: Will the wipes dry out in the pack?
A: Most feedback praises the resealable pack. One Amazon reviewer said it “seals really well” and keeps wipes from drying out. A smaller complaint is that the opening can pull out more than one wipe at a time.
Final Verdict
Buy if you’re a daily cleanser‑wipe user, traveler, gym‑goer, or someone with normal‑to‑dry skin who wants a soft, non‑tight after‑feel and a cooling scent. Avoid if you’re fragrance‑averse, mint‑sensitive, or rely on wipes as your only remover for waterproof eye makeup. Pro tip from the community: if you like the cloth and feel but not the aroma, users often switch to another Burt’s Bees scent or the Sensitive version to keep the same wipe texture without the sting.
