ESR AirPods Pro Case Review: Strong Buy Verdict
The ESR AirPods Pro Case with MagSafe has gained a reputation for delivering far more than the average third-party protective cover. Across Amazon, Reddit, and Trustpilot, the sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with users praising its magnetic lid, drop protection, and MagSafe compatibility. Based on aggregated feedback, this case earns a solid 9.2/10—valued for its durability and thoughtful design, though minor complaints about bulk and adhesive longevity persist.
Quick Verdict: Yes — Strong buy for users seeking secure lid closure, MagSafe convenience, and premium protection at a mid-range price.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Strong magnetic lid prevents accidental openings | Some models are slightly bulkier than slim silicone cases |
| Durable hybrid shell with shock absorption | Adhesive strip for lid may loosen over time |
| MagSafe & Qi wireless charging compatibility | Magsafe charging can be inconsistent with non-OEM chargers |
| Visible status light cutout | Does not fit AirPods 1/2 |
| Includes cleaning brush, removal tool, and strap | Certain colors go out of stock quickly |
| Multiple color options | Orbit model incompatible with Apple Watch charger |
Claims vs Reality
ESR markets the case as “MagSafe ready” with “powerful drop protection” and a “magnetic locking lid.” On paper, it’s a sleek hybrid shell with an ultra-hard exterior and flexible core, designed to keep AirPods looking brand new.
While the MagSafe compatibility is widely confirmed, there’s nuance. A verified buyer on Amazon noted: "It worked perfectly with my OEM MagSafe charger, but my Anker aftermarket charger wouldn’t recognize it." This aligns with Reddit reports that third-party watch chargers can fail to work with certain ESR models, suggesting that while officially rated for MagSafe, compatibility is most reliable with Apple’s own chargers.
Drop protection claims are backed up by everyday experiences. One Amazon reviewer shared: “I’ve dropped it countless times and it doesn’t have a single scratch or dent, and my AirPods are ok every time.” This durability is exactly what ESR promises, and users confirm the case absorbs shock without adding excessive bulk.
The “magnetic locking lid” is perhaps the most validated claim. Reddit user feedback, such as “I can’t go back to cases without magnets — all other cases let AirPods fall out when dropped”, reinforces that this feature solves a real-world problem Apple’s stock case leaves unaddressed.
Cross-Platform Consensus
Universally Praised
The standout praise centers on the magnetic lid mechanism. For commuters and travelers, this feature prevents earbuds from spilling during drops or jostling in bags. A verified buyer on Amazon wrote: “The magnets are strong and hold well. Compared to other cases, they would easily open in my pocket but this one stays shut.”
Durability is another universal win. Reddit users describe years-long usage without wear: “Had an ESR case on my Pro 2 for three years with no problems.” The hybrid shell, combining hard polycarbonate and a shock-absorbing core, proves effective against scratches from keys or coins.
MagSafe charging convenience surfaces repeatedly. For nightstand users, the tap-and-go charging eliminates cable fuss. One Amazon user reported: “It even makes the 1st generation MagSafe compatible.” This retroactive compatibility is especially valued by owners of older AirPods Pro.
Common Complaints
Bulkiness is mentioned in several threads, especially for the Cyber Armor Tough model. A Reddit user admitted returning it because “the cyber case was too bulky… waiting for the Pulse case because it’s slimmer.” This suggests style-conscious users may prefer the Orbit or Cloud Soft variants.
Adhesive longevity is another recurring issue. An Amazon reviewer shared: “You have to glue the lid to your AirPods Pro and mine came off after about a month of daily usage… they’re sending me a replacement.” While ESR’s customer service responds quickly, the reliance on adhesive strips for lid security is a weak point.
Charging inconsistency with non-OEM accessories frustrates some owners. As one Reddit user put it: “Orbit doesn’t work with my Apple Watch charger, but it says MagSafe compatible. Should work with MagSafe charger. I don’t own one, prefer cable charging.”
Divisive Features
The included lanyard divides opinion. Some appreciate the carry convenience—“Handy lanyard to hold on and keep track of the headphones”—while others find it intrusive: “Don’t like the extra lanyard sticking out.”
The thickness of certain models also polarizes buyers. Protection-focused users welcome the heft, but minimalists lean toward ESR’s slimmer designs. This trade-off between sleekness and security runs through multiple Reddit comparisons.
Trust & Reliability
Trustpilot and Reddit histories show ESR’s reputation for responsive customer support. One Amazon buyer recounted: “Contacted manufacturer support… they got back to me within a day or two and are now sending me a replacement.”
Long-term users report consistent performance over years. Reddit user testimony like “Had that same ESR case since I got my Pro 2—crazy good” suggests the materials resist wear beyond cosmetic scuffs.
However, Fakespot analysis flags potential review manipulation on Amazon, estimating over 2,400 altered reviews. While overall sentiment remains high, buyers should weigh cross-platform feedback more heavily than Amazon scores alone.
Alternatives
The most discussed competitor is Dbrand. While some users enjoy Dbrand’s aesthetics, complaints about backorder delays and higher price are common. One Redditor noted: “No idea why I spent $35 on the Grip… ESR is incredible for more than half the price.”
Pitaka is mentioned as a premium alternative—slimmer and stylish—but at a significantly higher cost. For budget-conscious buyers, ESR’s blend of protection, features, and price wins out, especially when compared to Spigen or Catalyst, which target niche needs like waterproofing.
Price & Value
Amazon listings range from $13.99 for Cloud Soft models to $23.99 for Cyber Flicklock variants. This positions ESR well below premium brands while still offering bundled extras like cleaning brushes and removal tools.
On eBay, OEM Apple AirPods Pro charging cases sell for $24.99–$175 depending on generation and condition. Given this resale pricing, an ESR case under $20 is a cost-effective insurance policy against damage that could force a costly OEM replacement.
Community buying tips include waiting for Amazon sales or ESR’s direct-store promotions, where bundles with chargers or wallets can drop prices further.
FAQ
Q: Does the ESR case support wireless charging?
A: Yes, it supports standard Qi wireless charging, MagSafe, and HaloLock chargers. Users recommend pairing it with OEM chargers for best reliability.
Q: Will this case fit AirPods 1 or 2?
A: No, it’s only compatible with AirPods Pro 1st/2nd generation (2019/2022/2023). Reddit users confirm no ESR cases exist for AirPods 1/2.
Q: How strong is the magnetic lid?
A: Strong enough to prevent accidental openings during drops or in pockets. Multiple buyers describe it as “super strong” and far superior to non-magnetic cases.
Q: Does MagSafe work with aftermarket chargers?
A: Reports are mixed—OEM MagSafe chargers work flawlessly, but compatibility with third-party Apple Watch chargers can fail.
Q: What’s included in the box?
A: Case, cleaning brush, removal tool, adhesive strip for lid, and in some models, a carabiner or lanyard.
Final Verdict: Buy if you want secure lid closure, proven drop protection, and reliable MagSafe charging—especially if you commute or travel often. Avoid if you prioritize ultra-slim aesthetics over durability, or need guaranteed compatibility with non-OEM chargers. Pro tip from Reddit: choose your ESR model carefully—Orbit for slimmer profile, Cyber Flicklock for maximum security.
