Canon PGI-35/CLI-36 Review: Quality Prints, High Cost Verdict
A surprising takeaway from user reports is that the Canon PGI-35/CLI-36 Black and Color Value Pack consistently delivers bright, professional-quality prints even from compact portable printers, yet many buyers say the cost-per-page feels steep compared to other ink systems. Based on cross-platform sentiment, this product earns an 8.5/10 for performance and reliability, but scores lower on value for high-volume users.
Quick Verdict: Conditional
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Sharp, professional text output | High price per page for heavy users |
| Vivid, lifelike color reproduction | Small ink tanks mean frequent replacements |
| Easy installation, even for first-time users | Color cartridge depletes faster than black |
| Reliable compatibility with PIXMA iP100, iP110, TR150 | Limited high-yield options |
| Consistent performance to last page | OEM pricing feels high compared to third-party |
| Works well in portable/mobile setups | Not ideal for large batch printing |
Claims vs Reality
Canon markets this value pack as a high-quality, reliable ink set designed to "deliver consistent results at a great value." They highlight features like easy installation and OEM-level performance. While user feedback strongly supports the quality claim, the "great value" message is more contested.
For example, while Canon lists the PGI-35 black as yielding around 190 pages and the CLI-36 color at 250 pages, Reddit discussions often mention quicker depletion. One verified Trustpilot reviewer noted: "Works well. Doesn’t print as many simple pages as I would like. I think the price is too high compared to other printer inks." This suggests that while the cartridges meet ISO page yield standards, real-world usage—especially in photo printing—can shorten lifespan.
Another marketing point is that OEM cartridges ensure device longevity and optimal performance. This is reinforced by users who avoid third-party ink due to reliability concerns. A verified buyer on Amazon commented: "Not really tempted by third party vendors—ink is such a fundamental component of printer performance that any compromise doesn’t seem a good idea."
Cross-Platform Consensus
Universally Praised
Across Amazon, Trustpilot, and Reddit, the print quality stands out as the most celebrated feature. Portable printer users, in particular, appreciate that even small units like the PIXMA iP100 produce crisp text and vivid photos. A Trustpilot reviewer enthused: "Bright color pictures when you use this ink!" For mobile professionals, such as traveling salespeople or event photographers, the ability to produce high-quality output on the go is a significant advantage.
Ease of installation is another point of universal praise. Reddit users describe swapping cartridges as “only taking a few moments” and note a precise fit that minimizes downtime. This benefits remote or mobile users who need quick turnarounds without technical hassle.
Reliability is also a recurring highlight. Multiple Amazon reviewers report no failures across repeated purchases, with one stating: "I’ve purchased a few times and they never fail." This long-term performance builds trust among those who rely on portable printers for both documents and client-facing materials.
Common Complaints
The most frequent complaint is the relatively small ink capacity, leading to frequent replacements. High-volume users find the cost per page troubling. A verified Amazon buyer wrote: "Quite small ink tanks, but adequate for my use… not really tempted by third-party vendors." This underscores that while low-volume users may tolerate the capacity, regular batch printing quickly becomes expensive.
Another issue is uneven depletion rates between black and color cartridges. Trustpilot feedback reveals frustration when color runs out well before black, disrupting balanced usage. One reviewer noted: "Printer kept working but with impaired quality when the color tank ran out… despite warnings about the black tank nearing empty, the printer worked fine until it just stopped completely."
Divisive Features
The debate over OEM versus compatible cartridges is sharply divided. Some Reddit and Quora contributors insist compatible options like True Image deliver similar quality at lower prices, citing page yields up to 350 for tri-color. Others remain loyal to Canon's OEM supply due to fears of compatibility issues or printhead damage. This divide reflects different risk tolerances—budget-conscious buyers may experiment with third-party ink, while professionals prioritize reliability.
Trust & Reliability
Trustpilot reviews suggest strong confidence in Canon's OEM cartridges, with many repeat buyers highlighting consistent quality over years of use. One long-term user shared: "These are legitimate and last a long time. I’ve purchased a few times and they never fail." This pattern indicates minimal concerns about defective units or premature drying when stored properly.
Scam or counterfeit fears are minimal in official channels like Amazon and Canon's own store. However, eBay listings prompt some users to caution against unbranded bulk packs without proven track records, especially given the prevalence of “compatible” inks that may not match OEM standards.
Alternatives
The most discussed competitor is True Image's compatible PGI-35/CLI-36 set, which offers lower prices and higher advertised yields (200 pages black, 350 tri-color). Reddit user feedback praises its color vibrancy and cost savings but admits installation quality varies slightly from Canon's own cartridges. Lometic’s compatible pack is another option, with yields of 260 pages black and 310 color, appealing to moderate-volume home users seeking savings.
Price & Value
Pricing varies widely—Canon Canada lists the pack at $45.99, while Amazon offers OEM two-packs around $11.95. eBay bulk deals, such as 12-pack compatible sets at $18.29, significantly cut per-cartridge costs but introduce compatibility risks. Community buying tips emphasize watching for sales, using official channels to avoid counterfeits, and considering compatible brands only after verifying printer warranty implications.
FAQ
Q: Does the Canon PGI-35/CLI-36 value pack work with all PIXMA printers?
A: No, it’s designed for specific models like PIXMA iP100, iP110, and TR150. Always check your printer’s manual before purchasing.
Q: How many pages can I print before replacing cartridges?
A: OEM specs rate black at ~190 pages and color at ~250 pages under standard coverage. Real-world yields may be lower for photo printing.
Q: Are compatible cartridges safe to use?
A: Many users report success with brands like True Image, but OEM supporters warn of potential printhead issues. Compatibility depends on printer model and usage.
Q: Why does my color cartridge run out faster than black?
A: Color printing, especially photos, consumes more ink per page. Uneven depletion is common and can disrupt balanced usage.
Q: How should I store spare cartridges?
A: Keep them sealed in original packaging, in a cool, dry place away from sunlight, to prevent evaporation and maintain ink quality.
Final Verdict: Buy if you’re a portable printer user prioritizing OEM reliability and consistent quality for professional text and photo output. Avoid if you’re a high-volume user sensitive to cost-per-page. Pro tip from the community: stock up during official sales to offset OEM pricing and ensure product authenticity.
