Apple Magic Keyboard iPad Pro Review: Buy or Skip?
For many iPad Pro owners, the Apple Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro (Renewed, Black) sits at the top of the accessory wishlist—but digging into cross-platform feedback reveals a complex picture. Rated consistently high on Amazon (4.6/5) and Best Buy (4.7/5), users praise its typing feel, build quality, and trackpad integration. Yet, persistent complaints about its weight, price, and certain design quirks mean it’s not a universal fit. Based on aggregated sentiment, it lands at 8.4/10—excellent for productivity-focused users, less convincing for casual tablet use.
Quick Verdict: Conditional Buy
| Pros (User-Reported) | Cons (User-Reported) |
|---|---|
| Premium build quality with metal deck | Expensive compared to alternatives |
| Excellent typing feel, backlit keys | Adds significant weight to iPad |
| Large, responsive trackpad with haptic feedback | Limited viewing angles for drawing |
| Magnetic attachment is fast and secure | No data transfer via USB-C port |
| Function key row improves workflow | Rocking motion when tapping screen |
| Seamless iPadOS integration | White model prone to dirt and smudges |
Claims vs Reality
Apple markets the Magic Keyboard as “the perfect companion for iPad Pro” with a comfortable typing experience, adjustable floating design, and a trackpad that “opens up new ways to work.” While many users agree on the typing quality, the floating cantilever design doesn’t suit every scenario. Reddit user u/Track*** admitted: “I can do coding and articles on my iPad Pro, but I don't think it's productive or efficient… think twice before buying.” This reflects a gap between Apple’s promise of desktop-like productivity and the reality of tablet workflows.
Another claimed benefit—the USB-C port for charging—comes with a caveat. Digital Trends notes it’s “exclusively for charging” and does not support data transfer, frustrating those who expected MacBook-like versatility. Best Buy reviewers echoed this, appreciating the convenience but wishing for more functionality.
The trackpad is heavily promoted for precision tasks. In practice, users do find it responsive, but some—like a verified Best Buy buyer—use touch more often: “I seldom use the trackpad… opt to use touch screen most of the time.” This suggests that while the hardware is solid, the software ecosystem determines its full utility.
Cross-Platform Consensus
Universally Praised
Across Reddit, Best Buy, and Trustpilot, the typing feel is the standout feature. The scissor mechanism with 1mm travel earns comparisons to MacBook keyboards. Reddit user u/Track*** summed it up: “Best typing experience on the iPad… no better accessory out there.” Best Buy shopper “trent” gushed over the “tactical keys” and build quality, calling it “vintage Apple.”
The trackpad’s haptic feedback is another win. Best Buy’s “damian” described it as “a marked improvement” over older models, while Trustpilot reviewers praised its large size for editing tasks. For writers, students, and remote workers, the combination of precise cursor control and solid typing is transformative.
Build quality consistently earns top marks. Trustpilot reviewers highlight the “pleasant, quiet key travel” and “no disconnects in two years of use” on similar Apple keyboards. The metal palm rest and tight hinge add to a premium feel that outclasses cheaper competitors.
Common Complaints
Weight is the most persistent issue. Reddit user u/M4Pros*** called it “as heavy as the old version” and noted they leave it behind unless typing is essential. Best Buy’s “anonymous” said it “weighs about the same as the iPad alone,” doubling overall heft.
The rocking motion when tapping or drawing on the screen is a newer gripe, especially with the 2024 redesign. Digital Trends warns the “whole assembly rocks and wants to topple over” when interacting with the top half of the display, making it unsuitable for lap use during certain tasks.
Price is another sore spot. Best Buy’s “nh techie” called the $349 tag “insulting” without an outlet discount. Reddit threads often advise cheaper alternatives like the Smart Keyboard Folio if typing is infrequent.
Some users dislike the limited tablet mode. As Quora’s Apple Community pointed out, “the iPad cannot be used as a tablet when attached,” forcing owners to detach it for touch-heavy work or art.
Divisive Features
The function key row is celebrated by productivity users but seen as nonessential by casual ones. Reddit user u/M4Pros*** liked the “volume and app switcher” buttons, while others argue they rarely use them.
Trackpad usage splits opinion: heavy typists love it, tablet-first users often ignore it in favor of touch.
Aesthetic choices also divide. White models look striking but are prone to dirt. Digital Trends and multiple Best Buy reviewers warn they “show smudges and grime” quickly, while black hides wear better.
Trust & Reliability
Trustpilot feedback points to strong reliability: “No disconnects or micro outages” over two years, even under heavy daily use. This contrasts with Apple Community reports of a persistent iPadOS bug causing keyboard failure during multitasking, forcing sleep/wake cycles to restore function. One long-time iPad Pro owner said, “I regret spending $350… this unreliable.”
These software-related issues seem platform-wide, affecting other Apple keyboards too, suggesting the hardware’s durability is solid but dependent on OS stability.
Alternatives
Logitech’s Combo Touch is the most-mentioned rival. Reddit users note it’s cheaper, includes a pen holder, and offers a case that protects the iPad when detached. However, multiple posters dismissed its build as “cheap” and “wouldn’t last,” favoring the sturdiness of the Magic Keyboard.
The Smart Keyboard Folio is lighter and cheaper, but lacks key travel and trackpad functionality. Reddit user u/Track*** found switching to the Magic Keyboard “night and day different” for typing quality.
Price & Value
eBay listings show renewed units for 12.9-inch models between $129–$189, far below retail. Amazon Renewed offers 45% off ($189 vs $349), making it more accessible. Reddit users recommend outlet or refurbished buys to soften the blow.
Resale value holds well—used units still fetch $135–$166 on eBay—reflecting sustained demand.
Buying tips from the community:
- Check for OS bugs before purchase if multitasking is key.
- Avoid white if dirt visibility is a concern.
- Consider weight in your daily carry.
FAQ
Q: Does the Magic Keyboard work with all iPad Pro models?
A: No. Compatibility depends on generation. The renewed black model supports 12.9-inch iPad Pro from 3rd gen onward, but newer 2024 designs fit only lighter M4 models.
Q: Can the USB-C port transfer data?
A: No. User reports confirm it’s charging-only, despite its location suggesting otherwise.
Q: Is it good for drawing with Apple Pencil?
A: Not ideal. The rocking motion and viewing angles make it awkward for upper-screen Pencil work; detaching the iPad is recommended.
Q: Will it replace a laptop?
A: For many writers and students, yes—it offers near-MacBook typing and trackpad. But heavy multitaskers or coders may find iPadOS limitations frustrating.
Q: How is the durability over time?
A: Build quality is excellent, with years of reliable use reported, though OS bugs can affect function.
Final Verdict
Buy if you’re a productivity-focused iPad Pro user who types daily and values premium build quality with integrated trackpad. Avoid if you prioritize light weight, frequent tablet mode, or need robust art/drawing ergonomics. Pro tip from Reddit: “Get it refurbished or outlet—same quality, half the price.”
